But the judge described the incident as an 'awful accident'
and dismissed the case.
The courtroom showdown between the former couple took a
surprising turn, with Usher extending the proverbial olive branch to a
distraught Raymond by embracing her. The 34-year-old RnB star tentatively
approached, before placing his hand on her shoulder.
Before dismissing the case, Fulton County Superior Court
Judge John Goger said he wasn't certain anyone really could have done anything
to prevent the accident. But he also advised Usher to keep his ex-wife well
advised of his whereabouts and who's taking care of the children.
The pair's boy fell to the bottom of the pool and became
stuck in the drain on Monday, according to an Atlanta police report. A
housekeeper tried unsuccessfully to free him. A contractor doing work at the
home pulled the boy from the pool and performed CPR. The boy was 'conscious,
alert and breathing' when emergency medical workers arrived, police said. He
was still in the hospital Friday.
'They're just assessing him,' Raymond told reporters outside
the courthouse after the hearing. 'There is a lot we don't know. I mean you
can't - it's only been a few days so we're very thankful that he's obviously
alive but we still have to observe him and make sure that everything is OK.'
The filing had said the boy 'suffered a near-death accident'
while left unsupervised at Usher's home when the singer was out of town.
Contrary to what Raymond claimed, Usher's aunt was poolside watching the
children when the older child became stuck in the drain, and Usher was at a
music studio one highway exit away, said the singer's lawyer John Mayoue.
Raymond used the episode to revisit the custody battle and
gain publicity, Mayoue said.
Raymond, who is a hair and wardrobe stylist, was emotional
during her testimony, at one point sobbing so hard that she had to step down
from the witness stand to regain her composure.
'He doesn't confer with me regarding anything,' Raymond
said, explaining that she never knows where Usher is, where the children are
and who's taking care of them.
Usher travels frequently and uses caregivers, including his
aunt, who aren't trained and qualified to care for young children, Raymond
said.
'I don't know where my children are, and I don't know who
they are with,' said Raymond as she took the stand. 'The caregivers he
introduced to me, I didn't know they had quit,' she said. 'Usher doesn't answer
the phone, he doesn't answer emails.'
Usher refuted the claims when he took the stand, claiming he
sends her a weekly email detailing the children's plans for the upcoming week.
'Every Sunday I send her a weekly activities, any doctor's
visits... summer camp, any information that's pertinent to their activities,'
he said. 'She can contact the children at any moment and any of the people who
will be with them at this time.'
Raymond's lawyer Angela Kinley also attacked Usher for not
calling his ex-wife to alert her of the accident until about 45 minutes after
it happened. Usher testified that he wanted to try to get information about how
serious it was and his son's injuries before calling her.
'I have always loved and appreciated my sons but tragedies
and close calls make this even more evident,' continued the stylist. Referring
to her late son, she added: 'URV had an angel named Kile Ishmael and our Lord
and true savior to look after him. Words cannot express the relief and how
thankful to God I truly am. Thank you Jehovah God, Jesus and Kile... Also, the
AV worker that saved my son is my hero! Period.'
She also wrote earlier in the day: 'I'm very happy this
morning, my son is resting well... we had a SpongeBob marathon ALLL night, he
wouldn't go to sleep! Thank you for the prayers.'
Usher and Raymond married in 2007 and divorced two years
later. They went through a lengthy child custody battle, and Usher last year
was awarded primary custody of the boys.
No comments:
Post a Comment